Gravity Fed vs. Pellet Smokers: Full Comparison Guide

Comparison of gravity fed and pellet smokers highlighting differences in flavor, fuel use, and performance

Gravity Fed vs. Pellet Smokers: Breaking Down the Best Choice for Your BBQ Style

Before you invest in your next smoker, it's worth understanding how gravity fed and pellet smokers stack up across the things that matter—flavor, consistency, maintenance, and performance. Whether you're new to BBQ or a seasoned pitmaster, this guide will help you make the right call for your cooking style.

Flavor Profile: Charcoal & Wood vs. Pellets
Fuel Efficiency and Burn Time
Heat Retention and Build Quality
Maintenance and Reliability
Cooking Temperature Range
Competition-Ready Results
Final Verdict
About Myron Mixon Gravity Fed & Pellet Smokers

Flavor Profile: Charcoal & Wood vs. Pellets

When it comes to BBQ, flavor is everything. The choice between a gravity fed smoker and a pellet smoker starts with how they create smoke.

Gravity fed smokers burn lump charcoal and wood chunks. This combo produces bold, complex, and layered smoke that infuses deep into the meat, offering a competition-grade flavor that pitmasters crave.

Pellet smokers use compressed wood pellets fed by an auger. The smoke is cleaner and lighter, which is great for a subtle profile—but often lacks the richness of traditional wood and charcoal.

✅ Best for: Cooks who want deep, old-school smoke flavor with every bite.

Fuel Efficiency and Burn Time

Gravity fed smokers use a vertical charcoal chute, feeding fuel downward as it burns. This design allows for long, steady cooking sessions—often up to 16 hours—without needing to refuel.

Pellet smokers burn pellets continuously via an auger system. While convenient, they often consume more fuel over time, especially in cold or windy weather.

✅ Best for: Long cooks and overnight smoking sessions with minimal refueling.

Myron Mixon Gravity Fed Smoker with Meat

Heat Retention and Build Quality

Myron Mixon Gravity Fed Smokers are built with thick steel and heavy-duty insulation, delivering excellent heat retention even in tough weather.

Pellet smokers vary widely. Some premium models hold temp well, but many entry-level options struggle with heat loss and recovery times.

✅ Best for: Year-round BBQ cooks who want consistent internal temps regardless of weather.

Maintenance and Reliability

Gravity fed smokers are simple machines—no fans, no electronics, no augers. Cleanup typically involves ash removal and occasional gasket checks.

Pellet smokers include more parts: motors, fans, and electronics that can break or require routine maintenance.

✅ Best for: Pitmasters who prefer a no-fuss, low-maintenance smoker.

Cooking Temperature Range

Gravity fed smokers offer a wide range from 225°F to over 400°F. You can smoke, roast, or grill on a single machine.

Pellet smokers are generally low-and-slow specialists. While some can sear, they don’t typically match the high-heat capabilities of charcoal without add-ons.

✅ Best for: Cooks who want the flexibility to smoke, roast, and grill.

BARQ 3600 Myron Mixon pellet smoker with large cooking capacity, WiFi controller, and competition-ready design Made in USA

Competition-Ready Results

Gravity fed smokers are the top choice of many championship BBQ teams due to their heat stability and flavor depth.

Pellet smokers offer ease and repeatability but can fall short of delivering the bold smoke profile that judges expect at high-level comps.

✅ Best for: Competitive cooks or serious hobbyists aiming for championship-level results.

Final Verdict: Which Smoker Should You Choose?

Choose a gravity fed smoker if you want bold, traditional flavor, year-round performance, and mechanical simplicity.

Choose a pellet smoker if convenience, set-it-and-forget-it simplicity, and modern features are your top priorities.

✅ Best for: Gravity Fed – Traditionalists, competitors, and flavor chasers.
✅ Best for: Pellet – Convenient, entry-level, or set-it-and-forget-it cooking styles.

	Gravity Fed Smoker	Pellet Smoker
Fuel Type	Charcoal + wood chunks	Compressed wood pellets
Flavor Profile	Rich, deep, traditional smoke flavor	Milder smoke
Fuel Efficiency	12–16 hours per load; slow burn	Efficient, but higher consumption over long cooks
Maintenance	Simple mechanical design, minimal parts	Multiple electronic components, more to maintain
Temperature Range	225°F to 400°F+	Typically 180°F to 350°F
Heat Retention	Exceptional, even in cold climates	Varies by build quality; can be less consistent in cold weather
Best For	Traditionalists, competitors, flavor-focused cooks	Convenience seekers, entry-level or casual users

About Myron Mixon Gravity Fed & Pellet Smokers

At DDR BBQ Supply, we carry the full line of Myron Mixon Gravity Fed Smokers, engineered by the winningest man in BBQ. Built for serious cooks, they offer durability, smoke control, and consistency you can count on.

Prefer pellets? Myron Mixon’s pellet smoker models combine ease of use with heavy-duty build quality, giving modern pitmasters a powerful tool for great results with minimal effort.

🔥 Whether you lean toward fire management or fuel-fed automation, Myron Mixon has you covered. Shop all Myron Mixon smokers now and find the setup that fits your BBQ style. 🔥

If you want to learn more, why not check out these articles below: