15 Best Burger Bun Alternatives Ranked | DDR BBQ Supply Blog

Shop hamburger essentials at DDR BBQ Supply – everything you need for perfect burgers, including BBQ rubs, sauces, cast iron, and grilling tools.

The Bun Isn’t Just a Holder—It’s Half the Burger Experience

You can grind your own brisket blend, layer on the best smoked bacon, and hit the perfect medium-rare temp—but if your bun falls apart or tastes like cardboard, that burger won’t be remembered. The truth is, burger buns matter more than most people realize. The right bun adds texture, flavor, and support. The wrong one turns your masterpiece into a soggy, sad mess.

Whether you’re building a classic cheeseburger, stacking pulled pork, or smashing patties on a cast iron flat top, this guide explores 15 of the best burger bun alternatives worth trying. We’re ranking them by structure, flavor, creativity, and how they pair with specific burger styles. If you’re looking for the best buns for burgers or exploring outside-the-box burger bun alternatives, you’re in the right place.

Pretzel Buns
Brioche Buns
Potato Rolls
Texas Toast
Waffles
Grilled Cheese Buns
English Muffins
Cornbread Slices
Ciabatta Rolls
Onion Rolls
Bagels
Focaccia Squares
Hawaiian Slider Rolls
Buttermilk Biscuits
Lettuce Wraps

1. Pretzel Buns

Texture: Dense, chewy, with a glossy crust
Flavor: Slightly salty and buttery
Best for: BBQ burgers, beer cheese burgers, pulled pork sandwiches

Pretzel bun burgers are big, bold, and satisfying. They stand up to juicy patties and heavy toppings like crispy onions or spicy mustard. Toasting them lightly enhances the chew and prevents sogginess.

2. Brioche Buns

Texture: Soft, fluffy, with a tender crumb
Flavor: Buttery and slightly sweet
Best for: Smash burgers, cheeseburgers, breakfast burgers

If you're searching for a rich, soft bite, a brioche burger recipe is the way to go. These buns bring an upscale touch to any burger build. Just be aware—they’re not the sturdiest if you go overboard on wet toppings.

3. Potato Rolls

Texture: Pillowy, with a slightly dense base
Flavor: Mild and buttery
Best for: Classic cheeseburgers, kid-friendly builds

Soft yet structured, potato rolls have enough give to be tender but enough body to hold a greasy patty. They’re a crowd-pleaser and make any burger feel like comfort food.

4. Texas Toast

Texture: Thick, crunchy on the outside, soft inside
Flavor: Buttery and garlicky
Best for: Brisket burgers, patty melts, double-stacked builds

Texas toast is a sleeper pick. Griddle both sides until golden, then stack your burger like a grilled cheese hybrid. It holds heavy toppings without falling apart and adds a serious crunch.

5. Waffles

Texture: Crispy outside, soft pockets
Flavor: Slightly sweet and bready
Best for: Brunch burgers, chicken burgers, bacon and egg stacks

Waffles give you that sweet-savory contrast that makes brunch food so addictive. Try pairing with bacon, fried egg, and maple-glazed sausage or pulled pork for a full-on flavor bomb.

6. Grilled Cheese Buns

Texture: Crispy and gooey
Flavor: Cheesy, buttery, indulgent
Best for: Smash burgers, meat-heavy stacks

This is a “once-a-year” kind of move, but it’s unforgettable. Use two grilled cheese sandwiches as your top and bottom buns. Pair with a thin patty and minimal toppings—it’s already rich enough.

7. English Muffins

Texture: Nooks, crannies, toasted bite
Flavor: Slightly sour and savory
Best for: Breakfast burgers, thin patty builds

Underrated in the burger world, English muffins toast beautifully and have a structure that handles egg yolks and cheese drips without getting soggy.

8. Cornbread Slices

Texture: Crumbly, cake-like
Flavor: Sweet and buttery
Best for: Pulled pork, brisket, spicy burgers

Use firm, pan-cooked cornbread sliced into squares or rounds. It’s messy, yes—but the sweetness pairs perfectly with smoky meat and heat. Try it with hot BBQ sauce and pickled jalapeños.

9. Ciabatta Rolls

Texture: Crusty exterior, airy interior
Flavor: Mild and rustic
Best for: Grilled chicken, veggie burgers, caprese-style builds

These buns offer structure and chew, ideal for when you want something that eats more like a sandwich. Use when layering with pesto, mozzarella, or roasted veggies.

10. Onion Rolls

Texture: Soft, with crispy onion bits
Flavor: Savory, with built-in allium punch
Best for: Patty melts, steak burgers, pastrami burgers

Onion rolls add flavor without needing more toppings. Toast lightly and pair with Swiss, sautéed onions, and spicy mustard.

11. Bagels

Texture: Dense, chewy
Flavor: Mild to savory (everything, onion, sesame)
Best for: Breakfast burgers, egg-topped builds, lox-inspired burgers

If you want a serious bite, bagels deliver. Be warned: they’re thick and not easy to compress. Ideal for small, dense patties or creative sandwich-style burgers.

12. Focaccia Squares

Texture: Crispy bottom, soft and airy center
Flavor: Herbed, olive-oil rich
Best for: Italian-style burgers, veggie burgers, mozzarella and tomato stacks

Cut into squares and toast until golden. Use when you want a burger that eats like a panini or flatbread sandwich.

13. Hawaiian Slider Rolls

Texture: Soft and springy
Flavor: Sweet
Best for: Pulled pork sliders, spicy chicken sliders, kid-friendly meals

These are ideal for party platters or when you’re using rich, smoky meats and need a little sugar to balance it out.

14. Buttermilk Biscuits

Texture: Flaky and crumbly
Flavor: Buttery and rich
Best for: Sausage burgers, brunch stacks, fried chicken burgers

Split a homemade biscuit and build low and wide. A sausage patty, fried egg, and pepper jelly between two halves is hard to beat.

15. Lettuce Wraps

Texture: Crisp
Flavor: Neutral
Best for: Low-carb builds, spicy burgers, Asian-inspired toppings

Use sturdy leaves like iceberg or butter lettuce. Wrap tightly and double up for structure. Best with thin patties and minimal wet toppings.

How to Pick the Best Burger Bun Alternative for Your Build

Bun Type	Texture	Best With
Pretzel Bun	Chewy, dense	Pulled pork, beer cheese, thick patties
Brioche	Soft, fluffy	Cheeseburgers, breakfast burgers
Waffles	Crispy, sweet	Chicken, bacon, egg
Texas Toast	Crunchy, thick	Brisket, double patties, melty cheese
Cornbread	Crumbly, moist	Spicy pork, BBQ sauce

Final Thoughts: Don’t Sleep on the Bun

Great burgers aren’t just about what’s between the buns—they’re also about the buns themselves. Whether you’re going for a sturdy pretzel bun to hold up brisket, a sweet Hawaiian roll to balance heat, or waffles to bring in a breakfast angle, changing your bun can completely transform your burger’s flavor and feel.

You can find our full lineup of hamburger essentials HERE.

Looking to build burgers worth remembering? Pair your bun pick with premium ground meat, one of our house BBQ rubs, and sauces from DDR BBQ Supply. Your grill (and your guests) will thank you.

Did our blog meet your needs? You might also find these guides helpful:

Visit Us at our Retail Store or Online BBQ Store

Our online BBQ store is open 24-7 but if you'd rather shop in person, visit our retail store in Northwest Arkansas. You can shop top-quality grills, smokers, the best BBQ rubs and sauces, accessories, and expert advice. Stock up on top-quality BBQ supplies to bring authentic smokehouse flavor to your backyard cookouts.

Natives to San Antonio, Texas we take Texas BBQ seriously and have a variety of items you won't find anywhere else.

Whether you're looking for something specific or just want to explore the best in BBQ gear, we’re here to help you cook with confidence. You’ll find top-quality grills, offset smokers, water cookers, gravity fed smokers. BBQ rubs, sauces, accessories, and expert advice you won't find online. Stop by and experience hands-on shopping the way it should be!

We're located at 14696 US Hwy 62, Garfield, AR 72732. We're open Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM. Come pay us a visit!

Better Gear. Better BBQ.™