Person trimming a large cut of beef while wearing black nitrile gloves

Some of the fat on the brisket melts into the meat while it smokes, and the meat stays moist because of that. The rest never melts. It stays as chewy lumps on your plate, and your seasoning ends up sitting on fat instead of meat. The thin, ragged edges are the other trouble, since they dry out before the thick middle is done.

That's why you trim a brisket before it goes in the smoker. You cut off the fat that won’t melt and even out the thick and thin spots, so that the whole brisket is done at the same time.

What this article covers

Why Should You Start With a Cold Brisket?

Cold fat is firm, which makes it easier for you to cut through. Fat that’s been sitting out goes soft and greasy, and the blade skids over it instead of slicing through. You can end up sawing at it and pulling off meat you meant to keep.

Keep the brisket in the fridge until your knife and board are ready. If it’s already warmed up, put it in the freezer for 20 to 30 minutes to firm it back up. Do the same if the fat turns slick partway through the trim.

Highly marbled raw beef brisket on a wooden cutting board

How to Trim a Brisket Step by Step

Sharpen your knife before you start, because a dull blade tears at fat instead of slicing it. None of this is difficult, but it’s slow work the first few times.

  1. Look the brisket over. Lay it fat side down and run your hands over it before you cut anything. Find the point (the thicker, fattier end) and the flat (the long, leaner section). Press along the seam where those two meet, feeling for lumps of fat that are hard rather than soft, and have a look at the thin edges along the sides. That’s where you’ll be working.
  2. Decide whether you’re cooking it in one piece or two. A whole brisket with both muscles still attached is called a packer. Cook it that way and you get more of the dark, seasoned crust all over, but the lean flat is done well before the fatty point is ready. If you separate them, each one comes off when it’s ready, but you lose some of that crust where you cut. Most people cook their first few as a packer. If that’s you, cut back the thick wedge of fat sitting in the seam and leave the muscles joined. If you’d rather cook them separately, work your knife into that same seam and cut along it.
  3. Cut out the hard fat. This is the dense, waxy fat that never melts. There’s usually a big chunk at the seam near the point and smaller pockets along the sides. Hold your knife almost flat against the meat and take it off in thin slices rather than digging under it, so you’re not pulling good meat away with it. Soft fat that gives under your thumb can stay.
  4. Peel off the silver skin. That’s the thin, shiny membrane on the meat side, and it stays tough however long you cook it. Slide the tip of your knife under one end until you’ve freed a flap big enough to grip. Pinch that flap, pull it up and away from the meat, and cut along underneath it with the blade angled slightly upward. Keep your free hand behind the blade, never in front of it. The knife travels flat and fast through this, and you can cut yourself badly if it slips off the membrane.
  5. Tidy up the thin edges. Look at the long sides of the brisket. They won’t be straight, and in places the meat can taper down to a thin flap. Those thin bits dry out and go hard in the smoker while the thick middle is still cooking. Cut them off so the sides run reasonably straight, and take the sharp corners off so nothing is left sticking out. Do the same at the narrow end of the flat. Cut across it until you reach meat that has some real thickness to it.
  6. Flip it over and shave the fat cap. The fat cap is the thick layer of fat on top. Turn the brisket fat side up, lay your knife almost flat against the fat, and cut off thin sheets with long strokes toward you. Keep going until the layer that’s left is about ¼ inch, about as thick as a stack of four quarters. Run your hand over the surface as you work to find the spots that are still too thick.
  7. Season it and put it back in the fridge. Leave it there until the smoker is up to temperature. The fat you’ve just evened out stays firm that way, and the brisket isn’t sitting out at room temperature while you prep the grill.

Raw beef brisket with a trimmed fat cap on a cutting board

How Much Fat Cap to Leave

We like to leave about ¼ inch of the fat cap.

The fat closest to the meat renders (melts) in the smoker and drips down over the brisket, and that’s what keeps it moist through a long cook. Leave the cap too thick, and the top of it never gets hot enough to melt. You end up carving into chewy fat, and your rub sits on that layer instead of the beef, so the dark, seasoned crust (the bark) never forms underneath. Shave it too close, and the lean flat has nothing covering it, so that end can dry out.

Once the cap is even, sprinkle your brisket seasonings over the fat, the meat side, and the edges, then pat them down gently to press the seasoning into the surface.

Adjusting the Trim for Hot-and-Fast vs. Low-and-Slow

Low-and-slow is smoking at 225 to 250°F for most of a day, and the trim above is built around that. The fat has hours to melt, so a little unevenness sorts itself out.

Hot-and-fast is running the smoker at 275 to 325°F and finishing a whole brisket in six to eight hours instead of ten to sixteen. Fat that would have melted over a long cook can still be sitting there at the end of a short one, so trim the hard lumps and the thick patches back further than you would for a slow cook.

What to Do With the Trimmings

Keep two bowls on the counter while you trim, one for the lean scraps of meat and one for the fat. You’ll have a surprising amount of both by the end.

The scraps are delicious brisket beef, so you can still use them. Put them through a grinder with a little of the soft fat, and you’ve got burger meat, or chop them up for chili. They’ll keep three to four months in the freezer.

You can make tallow with the fat, which is beef fat you’ve melted and strained so that it sets solid and keeps well. Cut it small, melt it in a pot over low heat for a couple of hours, then pour the liquid through a sieve into a jar and let it cool. Use it anywhere you’d use oil or butter for frying. It’ll keep about six months in the fridge, or a year in the freezer.

Jar of creamy white fat beside a wooden bowl with scoops

Trimming Is Hard Work on Your Hands

Trimming a whole packer is the same forceful motion over and over. You’re pinching a handle and pushing a blade through cold fat, and plenty of people finish with sore hands and wrists. If you have arthritis or carpal tunnel, you’ll feel it sooner.

Sharpen your knife before every brisket, since a sharp blade needs far less force from you. Put a damp towel under your board so it can’t slide. If pain is a problem, split the job into two sittings and put the brisket back in the freezer between them.

If that isn’t enough, the grip is usually the problem rather than the blade. A standard knife runs straight from tip to handle, so your fingers push the edge through the food. For a knife made for that problem, have a look at NULU. The blade of their knives curves under your hand, so the cutting force travels down through your palm and forearm instead.

Doug Katz came up with the first one in his garage after shoulder surgery left him unable to cook, then worked it into its current shape with designer Gordon Downey. Doug still uses it with his own arthritis and carpal tunnel.

Frequently asked questions

Can I trim the brisket the day before I smoke it?

Yes, and it makes cook day a lot easier. Wrap it in plastic wrap or put it in a large zip-top bag, then keep it in the fridge overnight so the fat stays firm.

How do I tell hard fat from fat that will render?

Press it with your thumb. Hard fat feels dense and waxy and barely gives, while the fat that renders in the smoker feels softer and dents under your thumb, even when it’s cold.

What if parts of the fat cap are already thinner than ¼ inch?

Leave those spots alone and bring the thicker areas down to match. Shaving the thin patches any further takes the cover off the meat underneath, which can make those parts dry out.

Do the point and flat need different trims if I cook them separately?

Give each piece the same treatment. The flat is leaner and thinner, so look extra closely for tapered ends that could dry out.